File a Claim

Grange Mutual:

Auto Glass Claims Call 1-800-951-9734

All Other Claims Call 1-800-445-3030

You can also file a claim at www.grangeinsurance.com *You will need to setup an account

Hanover Insurance Group/Citizens Insurance:

All Claims Call 1-800-628-0250

You can also file a claim at www.hanover.com

Motorists Mutual:

Auto Glass Claims Call 1-877-379-4669

All Other Claims Call 1-800-876-8766

You can also file a claim at www.motoristsmutual.com

Safeco Insurance

All Claims Call 1-800-332-3226

The Ohio Fair Plan

All Claims Call 1-800-282-1772 or 1-614-839-6446 if calling from outside of Ohio

You can also file a claim at https://www.ohiofairplan.com/Public/ReportedLoss.aspx

Progressive Insurance

All Claims Call 1-800-274-4499

You can also file a claim at http://claims.progressive.com/ *You will need to setup an account

Sandy and Beaver Insurance

All Claims Call 1-800-421-4693

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

Auto Glass Claims Call 1-800-728-6494

All Other Claims Call 1-877-467-2252

Foremost Insurance

All Claims Call 1-800-527-3907

You can also file a claim at https://www.foremost.com/claims/file-a-claim.asp

Claim Information